As a true connoisseur, I love every aspect of make up. But if I had to be honest, I would say that eyes are my favorite feature to... well, make up. Eyelashes play a significant part to that equation. I admit and my sister (and bank account) would gladly tell you that I am obsessed with my lashes and finding the perfect HG (Holy Grail) mascara for these baby blues greens. I actually have crappy eyelashes – they are short, straight, and light light brown. Ugh. Got the poop end of the gene pool on that one (thanks ma). But thankfully they can be improved with just a little bit of… mascara. First of all, any mascara works well after the very first application. I personally believe it’s completely deceiving. I mean even a Walgreens brand would make your lashes look good at first (okay that one made me throw up in my mouth a little). The question is… what are the real effects the mascara produces (length, volume, curl, color), what are the effect’s longevity throughout the day, and how long the actual tube of mascara will last producing these effects. Oh and the blacker the better in my book. I have tried oh so many (so so many) trying to find my favorite so I thought I would share some of my findings with the good of humanity and so you won't waste your time and money on bad products. Thankfully these are just the recent products that I have used that I can remember or the list would be longer. Oh the horror. 
* Benefit BADgal Lash Mascara - This one could be my all time staple. It gives an equal dose of curl, length and volume which I love and one tube seems to last me a really long time in comparison. Even though I like them, you have to make sure you can maneuver the large brush because as far as large brushes goes, BADgal takes the cake. (hmmm frosting). If I ever get frustrated not being able to find a mascara I like, I always revert back to BADgal.
Benefit Get Bent Mascara - What an awful follow up to BADgal. The tip of the brush is bent in order to enhance curlage, but oh it does not. Its hard to work and I continually poked myself in the eye and the tube dried up in like a week. Nothing to offer. Pass.
* Sue Devitt Microquatic Black Widow Mascara - This one was surprisingly good - especially since I am not a huge Sue Devitt fan overall. It had really good lengthening and made my lashes extra black which I love. It had a tad of volumization in there so its a good choice if you want dark, long lashes.
Urban Decay Big Fatty Mascara - Eeeew. No thank eew. I think I have even blogged before about how awful this mascara is. I take back what I said before - I don't think I even liked the first application of this
one. Clumpy, dry, no fun. Pass.
* Shu Uemura Mascara Basic - Genius mascara. Smooth, lasting application that provides severe length and curl that would even last through my sweaty work outs (the only one that would). Its the best "basic" mascara out there. Only downfall is that its waterproof (annoying removal) and doesn't get my lashes quite as dark, black, voluminous as I want. Its the most expensive out of the bunch but worth every penny.
Shu Uemura Fiber Xtension Mascara - Hmmm... I was hoping for Shu Uemura's Basic with volume and walah! perfection but not quite. Yes this mascara creates darker and fuller lashes than the Basic, but it also smudges a whole lot more and clumps up much easier. Pass.
Dior Diorshow / Blackout Mascara - Oh heavens to Betsy where do I begin? Diorshow Mascara is an absolute cult favorite... raved by every beauty blogger and is on every one's "Best Of" lists including Sephora and Allure. But I beg to differ. I was disappointed in this mascara. It has the large brush that I
love but it was blah and disappointing. No major length, volume or curl. I do not see what the fuss is all about. I even tried the Diorshow Blackout version and it was smudgy smudgy smudgy. Although it made my lashes very black, not worth the smudge-clumpiness. Pass.
BOURJOIS Yes to Volume! No to Clumps! Mascara - This purchase had to do with the fact that I was at Ulta and at the time they only had a few good make up lines available and I had heard of this mascara. But with its odd 3D shaped brush I could barely get it on my lashed because it just plopped and clumped on the base of my lash line. I didn't use it but a couple of days. Pass.
* Chanel Inimitable Mascara - HG? Probably the closest thing I have gotten to a HG mascara and have used it religiously the past three months. I believe it has the great combination of length, curl, dense color, volume and lasting power. I just love it. Eeeek. I don't have enough good things to say about it. Unfortunately I do feel like the tube dries up a bit quickly so I find myself buying a new one more often than I'd like. And its 27 bucakaroos.
Lancome COURBE VIRTUÔSE (Divine Lasting Curves) - This mascara is all about providing lasting curls. I will have to say that it did help with the curl (however not over-the-top curlin')... but it was
such sticky mascara it would rip my lashes out. I always curl my eyelashes after one coat (which isn't great for your lashes but whatever) and my eyelash curler would literally stick to my lashes. I can't risk it. Pass.
* Lancome Fatale Mascara - I have such a love/hate relationship with this product. There is not a mascara out there that will make your lashes darker and blacker. Love love that. However, it has a 3D comb brush and it is simply hard to coat your lashes without over coating and making them clumpy. It just takes some skill and time. After purchasing this product numerous times over the years, I still don't have it totally down. But the long lasting, dark, thick effect this produces, I will not give up. I will persevere!!!
MAC Mascara – Any kind - No no no no no. Niet. Nope. Uh uh. Get the hint? Everyone knows my love for MAC on every possible level (its disturbing really) but they make the absolute crappiest mascaras in the history of time. It makes no sense. I keep trying to give them another chance - like their new Plush Lash, but once again it sucks. Zoom lash, Fibre Rich Lash, they're all the same. Very sloppy, smudgy, clumpy mascaras. I wish MAC would hire me to help with these. Sigh... Until then, pass pass pass. 
* Talika Eyelash Lipocils - This is actually not a mascara but a conditioner for your lashes and I think its wonderful. I have the curse (another one???) that my eye lashes begin to fall out when I get stressed - which is like, all the time. Hello! So this is a well known conditioner that is supposed to help your lashes grow and be healthy after just 28 days, and it really is good stuff if you ever start having lash-health issues. Let's hope you don't!
* Maybelline Illegal Lengths - My all-time favortite cheap mascara. Only issue? Oh its discontinued. Cheese and rice this still makes me so mad. Thankfully, for now, you can still buy it on eBay. So every once in a while I will get a few tubes to have on standby. I do not understand why this product was discontinued. Its amazing and provides length to your lashes that rivals the best of the best. I would suggest you do the same and stock up.
* Maybelline mascaras - Although there's not another Maybelline mascara that really stands out to me (besides my beloved above), I just wanted to point out that overall I believe Maybelline to be the best at cheaper, drugstore mascaras, which most people besides my-psychotic-self invest in. So if you go this route, I would focus on this brand for sure. Even I, at times, revert back from time-to-tome to everyone's favorite bright pink and green Maybelline Great Lash. Overall good mascara.
* Cover Girl Lash Blast Mascara - This new mascara as actually been raved about in blogs, magazines here and there the past month or so but talk about good advertising... I only wanted to try this mascara because of the Drew Barrymore's commercial. I love her. So I tried it and surprisingly its okay. Not on the calibar of Chanel volume, but decent volume and length. I would say quasi-yes. Easy, breezy, beautiful Cover Girl. OMG I could soooo be on ANTM.
Clinque - I can’t write about Clinique's mascaras because I have refused to wear Clinique since high school. I have issues with it - just hate it and everyone's blind commitment to it. Sorry no ma’am.
* products I will purchase again
Okay so I think thats enough. There are so many I didn't write about and so many I still want to try such as: Imju Fiberwig Mascara, Tarte Lights, Camera, Lashes! Mascara, Stila Major MAJOR Lash Mascara, Two Faced Lash Injection, and Yves Saint Laurent Mascara Volume Effet Faux Cils (its actually been ordered and in the mail now and I am tres excited about it). Believe it or not, I don't like buying and trying products and having them not work out just for the fun of it. I am doing this for all of us. And its fun. :) Oh... and if you are using anything besides a Shu Uemura eyelash curler, you are simply an idiot wasting your time. Harsh, but true. I hope this helps if any of you desire to step outside of your CVS shopping box and into the world of luxurious mascaras. Your eyes won't regret it.